The Diverging Trends of Canadian and U.S. Oil Stocks Amid Rising Prices

The recent surge in oil prices has propelled the energy sector to the forefront of the S&P 500 Index, making it a standout performer in the stock market this year. However, Canadian oil and gas stocks seem to be lagging behind their American counterparts. The S&P/TSX Composite Energy Index has seen a modest increase of nearly four percent, whereas U.S. energy stocks have enjoyed a more robust rise of 8.6 percent. This stark contrast raises questions about the underlying factors contributing to the disparity.

Impact of Political Developments on Canadian Oil Stocks

On a recent Tuesday, a decline in the Toronto-listed oil group occurred following comments from former President Trump about imposing tariffs on Canadian oil starting February 1. This announcement sent ripples through the market, causing Canadian Natural Resources Ltd., the nation’s largest oil and gas producer, to drop as much as 5.5 percent, marking its worst trading day since October. The sentiment among investors has soured, with many reconsidering their exposure to Canadian energy stocks.

Canadian Natural Gas Stocks Under Pressure

The performance of Canadian natural gas stocks is equally concerning. Keyera Corp., a prominent pipeliner listed in Toronto, has been identified as the worst-performing stock within the MSCI World Energy Index this year. The underperformance isn’t limited to Keyera; other notable Toronto-based companies like Cenovus Energy Inc., ARC Resources Ltd., and Tourmaline Oil Corp. are also among the top ten underperformers. The ongoing volatility in the sector amplifies worries about the long-term viability of these stocks.

U.S. Stocks Outperform Amidst Tariff Speculation

The divide between U.S. and Canadian energy stocks became more pronounced after reports surfaced suggesting that Trump had communicated with Alberta Premier Danielle Smith regarding potential tariffs on Canadian oil. Following these developments, U.S. energy stocks outperformed their Canadian peers by an impressive 6.3 percentage points, marking the largest divergence since November 2020. Analysts believe the ongoing uncertainty surrounding tariffs is significantly impacting the investment climate.

Investor Sentiment and Market Speculation

Many analysts point to tariffs as the primary reason for the discrepancy between the two markets. Randy Ollenberger, an analyst at Bank of Montreal Capital Markets, emphasized that the uncertainty surrounding tariffs is deterring investors from Canadian options. “Why take on unnecessary risk when there are favorable U.S. oil and gas companies available for investment?” he noted. The prevailing mentality is pushing investors to favor U.S. stocks where prospects appear more stable.

Short Interest Trends Reflect Investor Skepticism

The threat of tariffs has contributed to increased short interest in Canadian energy stocks. For instance, the short interest in Exxon Mobil Corp is around 0.9 percent, while its Canadian affiliate, Imperial Oil Ltd., experiences a significantly higher short interest of 4.1 percent in Toronto and 10 percent for its U.S.-listed shares. This disparity underscores a growing skepticism about the potential for Canadian stocks to rebound in the foreseeable future.

Potential Impact of Tariffs on Stock Performance

Some analysts caution that if Trump proceeds with the proposed 25 percent tariffs on Canadian oil, stocks could see a further decline. According to analysts at Toronto Dominion Cowen, certain oil producers may face losses as steep as 12 percent if tariffs remain in place for an extended period. The analysts argue that current stock prices have merely factored in a low probability for tariff implementation, leaving room for downward adjustment.

Conclusion: The Future of Canadian Oil and Gas Stocks

In light of recent developments, investors are advised to focus on high-quality Canadian oil and gas equities as they weigh the uncertain landscape characterized by potential tariffs and policy shifts. Analysts from Royal Bank of Canada Capital Markets highlight that the outlook for these stocks in 2025 is less attractive compared to 2024, indicating a need for strategic adjustments in investment portfolios. As political factors loom large over the energy sector, only time will reveal how Canadian oil and gas stocks will weather the storm.

For the latest insights and updates, be sure to follow us on Bloomberg.com.